POLL: Would give to "STATE" your social media passwords to buy a gun in Illinois?

Discussion in 'Trapshooting Forum - Americantrapshooter.com' started by merlo, Feb 10, 2019.

?

Would you give up your social media passwords to buy a gun in Illinois or New York?

  1. Yes

    1 vote(s)
    2.4%
  2. No

    40 vote(s)
    97.6%
  3. Not sure.

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  4. It depends how long the state will keep the passwords.

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  1. merlo

    merlo Mega Poster Forum Reporter

    Social media includes sites like Facebook, and Americantrapshooter.com. Similar bills are pending in both states. New Dem governor in IL is all for this. New group of Dems in New York as well.

    I report. You decide.
    Merlo out
     
  2. Garry

    Garry Mega Poster

    What is the possibility that Big Brother already has our password?
     
  3. Jumanji

    Jumanji Well-Known Member

    You FUDers do realize that the law is asking for a *list* of your social media accounts, not your *passwords*. That's a pretty big distinction....
     
    Stl Flyn and Roger Coveleskie like this.
  4. Smithy

    Smithy Mega Poster Founding Member

    NO COMRADE JUMANJI !

    Both bills give the NY and IL State Police "access to your media accounts". From Rickyd on the other thread:

    The bill asks those applying for a gun license or renewing one to give up their log-ins and passwords to social media accounts for open searches going back three years; internet search histories would go back one year. The law would give state and local police the green light to investigate for "commonly known profane slurs used or biased language used to describe race, national origin, ancestry, gender, religion, disability or sexual orientation; threatening health or safety of another person, or an act of terrorism."

    https://www.dailywire.com/news/43232/illinois-bill-would-permit-police-examine-gun-hank-berrien
     
  5. Smithy

    Smithy Mega Poster Founding Member

    I see Comrade Jumanji hasn't voted yet.
     
  6. Jim/Canton

    Jim/Canton Mega Poster

    Silly question. Why would I be in IL unless I was in prison?
     
  7. possumskinner

    possumskinner Active Member

    Ah there it is. A yes vote. There must be a permanent dealer at Sparta. Just a guess. : )
     
    wpt likes this.
  8. Roger Coveleskie

    Roger Coveleskie State HOF Founding Member Member State Hall of Fame

    That was the governor's vote. Roger C.
     
    wpt and Just Joe like this.
  9. possumskinner

    possumskinner Active Member

    Oh my, Just thinking I might have to give up passwords to my adult dating sites. All the gals I chat with might be investigated too? This could be fun!
     
    wpt and Roger Coveleskie like this.
  10. BigMonty

    BigMonty Member

    Anyone with the name possumskinner would be quite the catch on your dating site. For the sake of the site don’t give up that password.
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  11. Stl Flyn

    Stl Flyn Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Two words, "Patriot Act"! Creating terror does not necessarily have to be religion, or politically motivated. I would not describe the participants of the Las Vegas concert as "scared". When you volunteer your true thoughts, and persona out into the public limelight when hiding behind a computer, there can't be a better line of information as to what you are about, or possible intentions. They don't need to access your account. Once they put your screen name to a individual, they don't need to access your account. It is already out there for EVERYONE to see.

    So, if you post stupid chit, you probably should be worried. Bottom line, don't post threatening stupid chit!

    By the way, have you read the bills? The only way they could ask for or obtain passwords, and access to your accounts would be by a court issued warrant. Again, if you don't post stupid chit, they won't go through the hassle and expense to obtain a warrant to see what your PM's say. If you are mentally unstable, you should probably be worried. That would probably be the next warrant search shootout.

    Look at the last Noiser shooting in Aurora. Failed background check system alert and FOID card issue. Only to be "Told" to give up his CC permit/gun without further follow up. What a joke that chit is.

    So, what are you worried about?

    Schizophrenia is a severe mental disorder that can result in hallucinations, delusions, and extremely disordered thinking and behavior. It can also snare followers of such thinking, and cause spread of terror, hysteria, falsehood, and alternative facts. ;)

    Oh, by the way, I don't go on social media, and I don't use passwords. :eek:
     
    Roger Coveleskie likes this.
  12. Kiehl

    Kiehl Well-Known Member

    Huh? This is social media. You used a password to login.
     
  13. Stl Flyn

    Stl Flyn Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Never heard of it!
     
  14. Kiehl

    Kiehl Well-Known Member

    Yes, I have read the bills. You will be asked for your social media account info to get a gun. That is without a court order. I don't go to IL or NY, so no skin off my back yet?

    Not all social media can be seen by the whole public. You may have a setting on Facebook that only allows friends to see your posts. That is why they will need passwords.
     
  15. Stl Flyn

    Stl Flyn Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    I call BS ( not yelling, or in any way hostile). So, where is it stated in these bills that they MUST access your accounts, and you MUST give your passwords in order to purchase a firearm without further cause, so they can see your personal messages and communication without court order?

    By the way, if you communicate out in public with someone that may be sketchy of sorts and has murderous tendency traits, that may cause a red flag for you. If it is done in personal closed communication, not so much, until they have reason to get a court order. Then you may want to head for the hills.
     
  16. Kiehl

    Kiehl Well-Known Member

    Stl Flynn please see Daily Wire quotes per Smithy. I also saw author interview on Fox. He defended getting passwords but would not say how long they would keep them.
     
  17. Kiehl

    Kiehl Well-Known Member

    More for Stl Flynn

    IN ORDER TO ASCERTAIN WHETHER ANY SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNT OR SEARCH ENGINE HISTORY OF AN APPLICANT PRESENTS ANY GOOD CAUSE FOR THE DENIAL OF A LICENSE, THE INVESTIGATING OFFICER SHALL, AFTER OBTAINING THE APPLICANT’S CONSENT PURSUANT TO SUBDIVISION THREE OF THIS SECTION, AND OBTAINING ANY LOG-IN NAME, PASSWORD OR OTHER MEANS FOR ACCESSING A PERSONAL ACCOUNT, SERVICE, OR ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATIONS DEVICE NECESSARY TO REVIEW SUCH APPLICANT’S SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS AND SEARCH ENGINE HISTORY, REVIEW AN APPLICANT’S SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS FOR THE PREVIOUS THREE YEARS AND SEARCH ENGINE HISTORY FOR THE PREVIOUS YEAR AND INVESTIGATE AN APPLICANT’S POSTS OR SEARCHES RELATED TO (I) COMMONLY KNOWN PROFANE SLURS OR BIASED LANGUAGE USED TO DESCRIBE THE RACE, COLOR, NATIONAL ORIGIN, ANCESTRY, GENDER, RELIGION, RELIGIOUS PRACTICE, AGE, DISABILITY OR SEXUAL ORIENTATION OF A PERSON; (II) THREATENING THE HEALTH OR SAFETY OF ANOTHER PERSON; (III) AN ACT OF TERRORISM; OR (IV) ANY OTHER ISSUE DEEMED NECESSARY BY THE INVESTIGATING OFFICER. FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SUBDIVISION, “SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS” SHALL ONLY INCLUDE FACEBOOK, SNAPCHAT, TWITTER AND INSTAGRAM, AND “SEARCH ENGINE” SHALL ONLY INCLUDE GOOGLE, YAHOO AND BING. Upon completion of the investigation, the police authority shall report the results to the licensing officer without unnecessary delay.https://www.africanglobe.net/headlines/york-social-media-passwords-buy-gun/

    The Bills in NY and IL are nearly identical (same author)
     
    Stl Flyn likes this.
  18. oleolliedawg

    oleolliedawg Mega Poster Founding Member

    Actually, 'possums are one of the cleanest animals to skin. Your chances of getting a disease from skinning a 'possum is very slim. Only us old fur trappers would know this while a damn city slicker would cringe at the thought. I encourage my wife to wear rubber gloves while skinning most animals as my skinning days are over-thumb arthritis makes it more difficult. Since she skinned 30 foxes and a few 'coons this year she'll admit listening to my advice-sometimes.
     
    Roger Coveleskie and wpt like this.
  19. Stl Flyn

    Stl Flyn Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Kiell,

    The bill in Illinoise is similar but DOES NOT say PASSWORDS as far as obtaining them or getting inside personal accounts and search information, other than what is out in public already.

    Also, let me highlight this sentence leading off that paragraph;
    IN ORDER TO ASCERTAIN WHETHER ANY SOCIAL MEDIA
    ACCOUNT OR SEARCH ENGINE HISTORY OF AN APPLICANT PRESENTS ANY GOOD CAUSE
    FOR THE DENIAL OF A LICENSE, THE INVESTIGATING OFFICER SHALL, AFTER OBTAINING THE APPLICANT'S CONSENT.

    I can't see how this law would not be challenged and won. It does not say what will happen if you don't give consent, or if the application will be denied because of denial. Either way, this law is not going to fly the way it is without serious challenges.

    NY bill pertains to carry and possession of a pistol, or revolver. I can guarantee you the password, and access to your computer for search engine tracing obtainment without further cause will be challenged in court and have to be removed. Does not matter what the clueless yahoo said about the bill, and it's meaning. It may pass and be signed but in the probation period will be challenged I would think. Like I mentioned, public information you post voluntarily is way different that being forced to give private information to obtain a firearm other than your identification.

    I am not saying I agree with any of this. Just that sometimes this kind of stuff comes back to bite us, and we will be paying $70 for a brick of .22 shells if you can get them, $180 for an 8 lb'er of pounder if you can find it, and $1500 for a plain basic AR before you know it.

    https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2017/s9191

    "FOR THE
    PURPOSES OF THIS SUBDIVISION, "SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS" SHALL ONLY INCLUDE
    FACEBOOK, SNAPCHAT, TWITTER AND INSTAGRAM, AND "SEARCH ENGINE" SHALL
    ONLY INCLUDE GOOGLE, YAHOO AND BING."

    In my opinion if you have the propensity to have to post everything you do, or what your thoughts are on social media while you are awake, you have a mental problem as it is.
     
  20. Stl Flyn

    Stl Flyn Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    One more thing, pertaining to the Aurora shooting in Illinois. If the local authorities are going to be responsible for all of this investigation, and time, where are the money and resources going to come from. Obviously in Illinois, the resources and communication were not sufficient to follow up on that nut job, after it was found that the system failed.
     
  21. Kiehl

    Kiehl Well-Known Member

    Sure it implies that. Your consent must be given to get the gun. jmho
    And btw I agree with almost everything you said. But this is Illinois. And things are not going to get better. Do you really think they are not going to ask what you said on firearm social medias when you are buying a firearm. Really? And those Bing govt searches wont pop up your name and passwords on other websites?
     
  22. Stl Flyn

    Stl Flyn Forum Leader Founding Member Forum Leader

    Oh, I know they will! I use the same name on many sites. Makes it real easy for them. That is why I say, don't say incriminating things out in public domain, thinking you are anonymous. You are never anonymous. Neither are your searches. I guarantee you, if you reach red flag status out here in the general public forums, they will know everything about you, down to your underwear preference, without needing your permission.

    Besides, I have had more background checks, fingerprints on file, mental and physical exams than probably 95 percent of the population.

    In Illinois, even though States have certain powers to legislate for their well being, they obviously can not over step certain boundaries. Just as a background check for you to buy a new gun from a licensed dealer is not unconstitutional, neither is it for a State to rule that all gun transfers within the state must be done through their FOID card system to be a legal transfer. Are they restrictive to some degree, yes, but still less than a CCW permit. It basically is a universal background check system, with identification similar to a driver's license. It is all about identification, accountability, and responsibility. That includes what you do with a legally obtained gun, including whom you sell it to.

    The people that are nuts on the outside are usually easy to identify as a danger to society, it is the nuts hidden on the inside that are difficult ones to identify. As I have stated previously, where would be a better place to look to find out what the mentality of someone is, than a place where they feel somewhat anonymous.